[It's the look on his face more than anything else that warns her that she's stepped into unknown territory. Something in her story hadn't settled well with him and without a basic understanding of the differing relationship this Roy has with his Dinah, it's impossible to know what she's missed.]

It wasn't his fault he had to leave. [And there's something hard to her voice this time because she's still not okay with Oliver allowing Roy to do it for him, but when had her opinion ever mattered to any of them?] He outed himself to keep Oliver's secret from coming out and then faked his death to start over. [The disapproval is heavy in her voice, thick with unresolved tension.]

He can't come back to Star now.